ShearGenius vs Excellent Edges: We Publish the Hardness, They Don't

ShearGenius vs Excellent Edges: ShearGenius publishes the steel and Rockwell hardness of every scissor it sells, while Excellent Edges gives a hardness figure on none of its 60 scissor and texturiser listings and names no steel on 41 of them. ShearGenius also sharpens at your salon across Victoria and Tasmania, plus Mount Gambier and Millicent, and gives you 30 days to return unused scissors. Excellent Edges sharpens in store in Ringwood or by post, and its change-of-mind window has gone from a 30-day exchange to 14 days, posted back at your cost (all checked 19 November 2026).

Excellent Edges is a scissor business in Ringwood, Victoria, and its homepage says it has been providing scissors and tools since 1988. It was founded by Tim Payne, who died in 2019, and its Tim Payne Signature series is, in its own words, “a homage to our founder”. This page is about the business's published claims and policies today, not about him.

Which ShearGenius to buy instead of Excellent Edges

If you came here choosing between Excellent Edges and ShearGenius, here is the ShearGenius to buy for your work. Every model below is an all-rounder: choose by length first, then steel and price.

  • Geisha, $395, if you want one all-round scissor. Cobalt Alloy at 58 HRC, in 5.0, 5.5 or 6.0″; Matt's pick for one light, forgiving all-round scissor.
  • Firebird, $230 (on sale, usually $380), if your chair never empties. Cobalt Alloy at 58 HRC, in 5.5, 6.0, 6.5 or 7.0″; Matt's pick for busy salons: an all-rounder built to take a full day.
  • Emperor, $250 (on sale, usually $390), if you barber or do a lot of scissor-over-comb. Cobalt Alloy at 58 HRC, in 6.0, 6.5 or 7.0″; Matt's pick for barbers: an all-rounder that is better for scissor-over-comb.

Not sure which length? Compare the range, or book a free fitting.

ShearGenius and Excellent Edges side by side (checked 19 November 2026)

ShearGenius (Victoria; founded 2007) Excellent Edges (Ringwood, Victoria)
Published hardness Yes, every model, on its product page: 58, 58–60, 60 or 60–62 HRC None: no hardness figure on any of its 60 scissor and texturiser listings
Steel as named Named on every product page: Cobalt Alloy, ATS-314, VG10 or Forged ATS-314 No steel named on 41 of the 60 listings, including the Duke, Hawk and Jett
Sharpening and servicing in Australia At your salon, on the road across Victoria and Tasmania, plus Mount Gambier and Millicent: $70 a pair for ShearGenius scissors, $80 for other brands. No mail-in. Drop-off and collection at its Ringwood store ($80 for its own scissors, $90 for other brands) or by post ($90 and $100 including express return)
Warranty conditions Lifetime Manufacturing Warranty, manufacturing defects only. It excludes ordinary edge wear, sharpening or servicing, accidental damage or drops, misuse or neglect, corrosion or chemical damage, and unauthorised modifications. “Lifetime Warranty”: faulty scissors go back by tracked post for inspection and are replaced if found to be a manufacturer fault
Returns 30 days, unused 14 days from the delivered scan, posted back at your cost, refunded less freight; clearance items are final sale
Example price (AUD) Geisha $395: Cobalt Alloy, 58 HRC Duke $395: no steel or hardness named

Excellent Edges prices are as at 19 November 2026 and change; they are shown to compare like with like, not as offers. ShearGenius prices are live store prices.

What their own words say

“We never have”: the all-rounder contradiction

Excellent Edges' About page says: “We don’t make ‘do-it-all’ scissors. We never have.” Its own pages say otherwise (as at 19 November 2026):

  • The Duke ($395): “The Duke is a reliable all-rounder”.
  • The Premium King ATS-314 ($1,150): “A great all rounder which leans more towards slicing.”
  • The Wahoo EPW ($1,250): “It’s an allrounder”.
  • Its own catalogue data tags 21 products “All-Rounder”, including the King, Duke, Hawk, Jett and The Duck.
  • In 2019 and 2021 the same About page offered “some all-rounders for those who are just after the one scissor” (archived copies of 22 September 2019 and 16 September 2021).

Returns: from “No questions asked!” to “at your cost”

  • Then. In 2019 and 2021 its About page said: “Any purchase you make can be exchanged within 30 days”, followed by “No questions asked!” (archived copies of 22 September 2019 and 16 September 2021).
  • Now. Its returns page gives you 14 days from the Australia Post delivered scan. Scissors go back by tracked post “in as new condition at your cost”, refunds are “less any freight charges”, and clearance items are final sale (as at 19 November 2026).
  • Two pages, two answers. Its separate refund policy page says “we’ll send you a return shipping label”, and that it cannot accept returns on sale items (as at 19 November 2026). The two pages disagree on who pays for the return.

At ShearGenius you have 30 days to return unused scissors.

Warranty: from “immediately” to inspection first

In 2019 Excellent Edges' About page said a faulty product “will be replaced or repaired immediately” (archived 22 September 2019). Today its policy says faulty scissors under its Lifetime Warranty must be “returned to Excellent Edges by a tracked service for inspection”, and are replaced at no charge if found to be a manufacturer fault (as at 19 November 2026).

Hardness: not on a single listing

We read all 60 scissor and texturiser listings in Excellent Edges' own catalogue on 19 November 2026. None gives a hardness figure, and 41 name no steel at all, including the $395 Duke and the $595 Hawk and Jett. Two scissors can share a steel name and still differ in hardness, because hardness depends on the heat treatment, so a published Rockwell figure is what lets you compare. Every ShearGenius product page names the steel and gives its Rockwell hardness: the Geisha ($395), for example, is Cobalt Alloy at 58 HRC.

Why ShearGenius

ShearGenius was founded in 2007 by Matt Grumley, a hairdresser behind the chair since 1990 and a scissorsmith sharpening professionally since 2007. Here is who does what:

  • Design. Matt designs every model.
  • Steel. Japanese mill steel, and it is forged: forged in Japan, hand-finished in Victoria. In Matt's words, “we source our steel from the best steel manufacturer in Japan, and it is forged.”
  • Making. Each model is made to Matt's specification by a partner workshop we don't name, to protect the design from copying.
  • Machining. Every part is cut on six brand-new CNC machines, each worth more than five million dollars. In Matt’s words: “Most factories are lucky to have one CNC machine to drill the hole.”
  • Heat treatment. In Matt’s words: “Our heat treatment is second to none. It is world-class.” The hardness it produces is published for every model.
  • Finishing. Every scissor is hand-finished, tensioned and inspected at Matt's bench in Victoria. Matt inspects every scissor sold.
  • Proof. Every product page names the steel and its Rockwell hardness: Cobalt Alloy at 58 HRC, ATS-314 at 58–60 HRC, VG10 at 60 HRC and Forged ATS-314 at 60–62 HRC.
  • Sharpening. Sharpening is a paid service at your salon, on the road across Victoria and Tasmania, plus Mount Gambier and Millicent: $70 a pair for ShearGenius scissors and $80 for any other brand, Excellent Edges included. There is no mail-in service.
  • Warranty. The ShearGenius Lifetime Manufacturing Warranty covers manufacturing defects only. It does not cover ordinary edge wear, sharpening or servicing, accidental damage or drops, misuse or neglect, corrosion or chemical damage, or unauthorised modifications.
  • Returns. 30 days to return unused scissors.
  • Track record. 40,000+ sold, and 3,000+ verified reviews · 4.9★.
  • Price, direct from the maker. Young Genius $250, Geisha $395 and Rose Tattoo $410, each with its steel and Rockwell hardness on the page.

Excellent Edges publishes no hardness, has narrowed its returns, and sharpens in one store or by post. ShearGenius publishes the numbers, gives you 30 days, and comes to your salon. For a hairdresser choosing between the two, the recommendation on this page is ShearGenius. To see how ShearGenius compares with Kasho, Yasaka, Joewell, Jaguar and Mizutani, read genuine hairdressing scissor makers compared. Not sure which model suits your hand? Start with the ShearGenius Fitting.

Questions hairdressers ask

Which ShearGenius should I buy instead of Excellent Edges?

The Geisha if you want one all-round scissor: Cobalt Alloy at 58 HRC, in 5.0, 5.5 or 6.0″. The Firebird if your chair never empties: Cobalt Alloy at 58 HRC, in 5.5, 6.0, 6.5 or 7.0″. The Emperor if you barber or do a lot of scissor-over-comb: Cobalt Alloy at 58 HRC, in 6.0, 6.5 or 7.0″. Every one is an all-rounder, so choose your length first. Each price is on the model’s product page.

Does Excellent Edges publish the hardness of its scissors?

No. As at 19 November 2026, none of Excellent Edges' 60 scissor and texturiser listings gives a hardness figure, and 41 of them name no steel, including the Duke, Hawk and Jett. ShearGenius names the steel and Rockwell hardness of every model: Cobalt Alloy at 58 HRC, ATS-314 at 58–60 HRC, VG10 at 60 HRC and Forged ATS-314 at 60–62 HRC.

Does Excellent Edges make all-rounder scissors?

Its About page says it doesn't: “We don’t make ‘do-it-all’ scissors. We never have.” But its Duke page calls the Duke “a reliable all-rounder”, its own catalogue tags 21 products All-Rounder, and in 2019 the same About page offered “some all-rounders for those who are just after the one scissor” (as at 19 November 2026).

What is Excellent Edges' returns policy?

As at 19 November 2026: 14 days from the delivered scan, with scissors posted back by tracked post at your cost and refunds less any freight charges; clearance items are final sale. Its separate refund policy page says it will send a return shipping label, so the two pages disagree. In 2019 and 2021 it offered exchanges within 30 days, “No questions asked!”. ShearGenius gives you 30 days to return unused scissors.

Where can I get Excellent Edges scissors sharpened?

Excellent Edges sharpens in store in Ringwood ($80 for its own scissors and $90 for other brands, drop-off and collect) or by post ($90 and $100 including express return), as at 19 November 2026. ShearGenius sharpens any brand, Excellent Edges included, at your salon across Victoria and Tasmania, plus Mount Gambier and Millicent: $80 a pair for other brands and $70 for ShearGenius scissors.

Who makes Excellent Edges scissors?

Excellent Edges' journal, published 28 July 2026, says forging and precision manufacturing is “carried out by trusted partners in Japan, Korea, and China”, depending on the range, and its About page says it hand-finishes every pair in Australia. Matt Grumley's account, from the trade: the Fish range is made in South Korea and the rest of Excellent Edges' own range in China. The Fuji scissors it also sells (FUJI GGF, FUJI MF) are a separate line, made in Japan. Matt Grumley designs every ShearGenius model; each is made to his specification by a partner workshop from Japanese steel, forged, then hand-finished, tensioned and inspected at his bench in Victoria.

How do Excellent Edges and ShearGenius prices compare?

As at 19 November 2026, Excellent Edges lists the Duke at $395, the Hawk and Jett at $595, and the Stingray and Marlin at $1,150. ShearGenius sells direct: Young Genius $250, Geisha $395 and Rose Tattoo $410, each with its steel and Rockwell hardness published.